Hearing on Rideout murder case wraps up

May 18, 2017 04:28 PM

The suspects in the murder of a Penfield father were in court on Thursday.

Craig Rideout was found dead in Yates County in July of last year. Investigators say his killer strangled him and poured acid on his face.

Advertisement – Content Continues Below

Two of Rideout's sons - Alex and Colin, along with his estranged wife Laura and her boyfriend Paul Tucci, all face murder charges. Investigators say they tried to cover up the crime by hiding evidence at Mendon Ponds Park and by cleaning up a scene at Craig Rideout's apartment.

The purpose of the hearing Thursday was to determine whether statements made by some of the suspects can be used in their trial and whether all four of them will be tried together or separately.

The Rideouts and Paul Tucci arrived at court together along with their individual attorneys. For most of the day, they sat listening as different investigators testified about their interactions and conversations with the family members both before Craig Rideout's body was found and after.

We also learned Thursday that the last ping on Craig Rideout's cell phone was in Yates County and when his body was discovered. Investigators there found a cell phone ringing in his pocket. The emergency contact on that phone was Craig Rideout's sister, the same woman who had initially reported him missing.

The lawyers also spent several hours questioning the deputies who first responded to Mendon Ponds Park, where Colin and Alex were allegedly caught trying to dispose of evidence from the crime scene. In court papers earlier this year, we learned that, according to deputies, Colin Rideout told investigators that he had helped his mother cleanup blood in his father's basement. Colin also told investigators that he had been told by his mother to dispose of the garbage bags.

The hearing continues Friday morning then it will be up to the judge to decide whether statements these suspects made will be able to be used in the case against them and whether all four will be tried together or separately.

The trial is expected to start on June 20th.  


Copyright 2017 - WHEC-TV, LLC A Hubbard Broadcasting Company


We no longer have Facebook comments on this site. Please visit our Facebook Page to join the conversation.