Buffalo Tops shooter sentenced to life in prison without parole
BUFFALO, N.Y. — The Buffalo Tops mass shooter was sentenced to life in prison without parole on Wednesday after he plead guilty to killing ten people in a racist attack.
Peyton Gendron, whose hatred was fueled by racist conspiracy theories he encountered online, cried during some of the testimony and apologized to victims in a brief statement. The sentencing started with impact statements from the family members of the victims. You can watch the full sentencing through our Buffalo affiliate.
You can read more about who the victims were here. Here are summaries of some of the impact statements:
- Kimberly Salter, wife of Aaron Salter: She shared Bible verses, including “you reap what you sow”. She said her family is wearing red for the blood that Gendron shed and black because they are in mourning. Aaron Salter was the store’s security guard and a retired Buffalo Police officer. He was 55.
- Simone, granddaughter of Ruth Whitfield: She said her family has strength in knowing that the legacy of Whitfield will outlive the legacy of her killer. She said that in prison “you will go from a name to a number…you will be shut away from the world.” Ruth Whitfield was on her way from visiting her husband in a nursing home and stopped at the store to get something to eat. She was 86.
- Wayne Jones, son of Celestine Chaney: He said “I hope you find it in your heart to apologize to these people, you did wrong for no reason.” Chaney had six grandchildren, one great-grandchild, and was a cancer survivor. He was 65.
- Mother of Roberta Drury: She said she has become permanently damaged by her daughter’s murder. “No punishment will ever reverse our loss.” Roberta Drury was originally from Syracuse but staying in Buffalo. She was 32.
- Niece of Geraldine Talley: Gendron can be seen crying after her message. The niece said she hopes Gendron prays for forgiveness. She said “I want you to stay alive and think of this every day of your life.” Geraldine Talley, one of nine children, loved to be by the water. She was 62.
- Barbara Massey, sister of Katherine Massey: She pointed at Gendron and said her sister was a teacher, her best friend, and “there’s nothing she wouldn’t do for people.” A male family member of a victim ran at Gendron. The victim impact statements were briefly on pause. Katherine Massey used to write for the Buffalo News. She was 72.
- Brother of Andre Mackniel: He said Gendron took the last part of his life. His 3-year-old nephew is calling for his father who died in the shooting. Andre Mackniel was at Tops that day to buy his 3-year-old son a birthday cake. He was 53.
The judge imposed separate sentences of life without parole, one for each victim, to run concurrently. She also denied giving Gendron youthful offender status, which might have given him a chance to reenter society.
“There was nothing hasty or thoughtless about your conduct. There are no mitigating factors to be considered,” Judge Susan Eagan said.
Gendron pleaded guilty in November to crimes including murder and domestic terrorism motivated by hate, a charge that carried an automatic life sentence.
Gendron, 19, wore bullet-resistant armor and a helmet equipped with a livestreaming camera as he carried out the May 14 attack with a semiautomatic rifle he purchased legally but then modified so he could load it with illegal high-capacity ammunition magazines.
Gendron also faces separate federal charges that could carry a death sentence if the U.S. Justice Department chooses to seek it. His defense attorney said in December that Gendron is prepared to plead guilty in federal court as well to avoid execution.
The sentencing in the attack, which was fueled by racist conspiracy theories he encountered online, resumed shortly after the disruption, which happened as Barbara Massey Mapps excoriated him for killing her 72-year-old sister, Katherine Massey. As Mapps shouted and pointed at Gendron, a person in the audience took a few steps toward him before getting held back.
You don’t know what we’re going through,” a man shouted as he was led away by court officers. For several minutes thereafter, family members hugged and calmed each other.
Eagan then ordered Gendron back in and let the proceeding resume after admonishing everyone to “conduct ourselves appropriately.”
“I understand that emotion, and I understand the anger, but we cannot have that in the courtroom,” she said.
The sentencing was a chance for loved ones of the dead, as well as people wounded in the attack last spring, to pour out their loss, anguish and ire.
Some, like Massey Mapps, angrily condemned him; others quoted from the Bible or said they were praying for him. Several condemned him for his deliberate attack on a Black community far from his nearly all-white hometown.
“You’ve been brainwashed,” Wayne Jones Sr., the only child of victim Celestine Chaney, said as sobs rose from the audience. “You don’t even know Black people that much to hate them. You learned this on the internet, and it was a big mistake.”
“I hope you find it in your heart to apologize to these people, man. You did wrong for no reason,” Jones said.
Kimberly Salter, the widow of security guard Aaron Salter, explained that she and her family were wearing “red for the blood that he shed for his family and for his community, and black because we are still grieving.”
Christopher Braden, a Tops Friendly Market employee who was shot in the leg, said he was haunted by seeing the victims where they lay as he was carried out of the store.
“The visions haunt me in my sleep and every day,” he said.
At one point, Gendron began crying himself.
Gendron, now 19, wore bullet-resistant armor and a helmet equipped with a livestreaming camera as he carried out the May 14 attack. He killed his victims with a semiautomatic rifle, purchased legally but then modified so he could load it with high-capacity ammunition magazines that are illegal in New York.
There were only three survivors after he shot 13 people, specifically seeking out Black shoppers and workers.
His victims at the Tops market included a church deacon, the grocery store’s guard, a neighborhood activist, a man shopping for a birthday cake, a grandmother of nine and the mother of a former Buffalo fire commissioner. The victims ranged in age from 32 to 86.
In documents posted online, Gendron said he hoped the attack would help preserve white power in the U.S. He wrote that he picked the Tops grocery store, about a three-hour drive from his home in Conklin, New York, because it was in a predominantly Black neighborhood.
While a life prison sentence is guaranteed for Gendron, he also faces separate federal charges that could carry a death sentence if the U.S. Justice Department chooses to seek it. New York state does not have the death penalty.
Gendron’s admission of guilt on the state charges is seen as a potential help in avoiding a death sentence in the penalty phase of any federal trial. In a December hearing, defense attorney Sonya Zoghlin said Gendron is prepared to enter a guilty plea in federal court in exchange for a life sentence.
The mass shooting in Buffalo, and another less than two weeks later that killed 19 students and two teachers at a Texas elementary school, amplified calls for stronger gun controls, including from victims’ relatives who traveled to Washington, D.C. to testify before lawmakers.
New York legislators quickly passed a law banning semiautomatic rifle sales to most people under age 21. The state also banned sales of some types of body armor.
President Joe Biden signed a compromise gun violence bill in June intended to toughen background checks, keep firearms from more domestic violence offenders and help states put in place red flag laws making it easier for authorities to take weapons from people adjudged to be dangerous.